Go back

The Dangerous Houses

Episode number: 1

Overview: Eighteen-year-old Brookelyn Farthing disappears in 2013 after attending a party in Berea, Ky.; 24-year-old realtor Lindsay Buziak is found brutally killed after showing new clients a million-dollar home.

Down The Hill

Episode number: 2

Overview: Thirteen-year-old Abby Williams and 14-year-old Libby German disappear while hiking on a popular trail; 13-year-old Dylan Redwine vanishes over Thanksgiving break while visiting his father in Vallecito, Colo.

The Midnight Murders

Episode number: 3

Overview: Florida insurance agent Carla Stefaniak vanishes in Costa Rica; 19-year-old college student Pravin Varughese disappears after a party in 2014.

Secrets in the Cars

Episode number: 4

Overview: After a night out with friends, Jaleayah Davis, 20, is found dead; Kelsie Schelling, 21, drives two hours to show her boyfriend a sonogram of their baby, but never makes it home.

The Gone Girls

Episode number: 5

Overview: In Mobile, Ala., young mother Danniella Vian, 25, disappears into thin air; 19-year-old Holly Moore's suspicious death still raises questions four years after her body is found hanging in her closet